From the monthly archives:

May 2010

Air Travel for Family of FiveMy last post about nonstop or connecting flights detailed the reason why I’m beginning to question my habit of always choosing the least expensive flight when traveling with my family.  After screwing around with connections that took me halfway across the country the wrong way, and then a harrowing flight wherein my life flashed before my eyes, I decided to take a look at three flights that represented flights we may realistically take as a family.

The Results

I checked a few different online outlets and ended up using Travelocity for this post.

Test Flight Number 1

Minneapolis to New York City June 22-29

Nonstop

Depart 11:15 am   Arrive 3:00 pm

Total Cost = $315  with taxes and fees $345 per person/$1725 for a family of five

Connecting

Depart 7:55 am  Arrive Chicago O’Hare 8:50 am

Depart Chicago O’Hare 10:40 am  Arrive New York City 1:55 pm

Total Cost = $208 with taxes and fees $250 per person/ $1250 for a family of five

Difference in Price = $475

The connecting flight would get us to NY over an hour earlier, and cost $475 less, so on this one, I still think I’d choose the connecting flight.  We’d have to face the early morning flight, but the morning of travel is a lost cause anyway.  I would try to pack a bunch of snacks to get everyone through until we arrived in NY, but even if I had to spend $100 on food, I think it would be worth it in this instance.  Of course,  there’s always the chance that something could go wrong at O’Hare, which has happened before resulting in a 27 hour “vacation” in Chicago for my daughter and me.  But I’m sticking with the connecting flight on this one.

That nonstop flight is so perfect though.  If the connecting flight arrived any later in the day, I would be very tempted by the direct flight.  Still, that $400 difference is a big deal to our family.  It would get us one night in a hotel in New York:)

Test Flight Number 2

Minneapolis to Denver December 23-26

Nonstop

Depart anytime beginning at 6:30 am.  Other flights 10:00 am,  2:08 pm,  6:55 pm.   2 hour flight.

Total Cost = $208 with taxes and fees $229/$1145 for a family of five

Connecting

The best price on connecting flights was also $208/$229.

Difference in Price = $0.00

Obviously, no question here.  The nonstop flight is the winner.  I was surprised that it was not more expensive to fly over Christmas to a ski friendly state.  Definitely something to consider, although Denver is very driveable from Minneapolis, and $1145 is a tidy sum to shell out for 3 or 4 days.

Test Flight Number 3

Minneapolis to Orlando March 26-April 2

Nonstop

Option 1: Depart 7:00 pm  Arrive 11:12 pm

Total cost =  $448 with taxes and fees $469/$2345 for a family of five

Option 2 Depart 6:00 am  Arrive 10:16 am.

Total cost =  $581 with taxes and fees $613 per person/$3065 for a family of five.

Connecting

Depart 2:08 pm  Arrive Chicago O’Hare 3:09 pm

Depart Chicago O’Hare 5:15 pm Arrive Orlando 9:22 pm

Total cost = $249 with taxes and fees $291/$1455 for a family of five

Difference in Price = $1510 or $$890.

Ugh, none of these options are any good.  I might pass this one up and just drive.  The nonstop flight departing at 6:00 am offers the friendliest schedule.  Though it’s early in the morning, you wouldn’t lose an entire day of a week’s vacation.  On the other hand, $3065 seems like a reasonable amount to get to Singapore, but not Orlando.

The flight connecting through Chicago isn’t too bad, although you do lose that entire day.  At $1455 for five people, it is $890 less than the next lowest flight.  There would definitely  be an expense for food and drink of about $100.  The problem with the nonstop in this scenario is that it doesn’t arrive until 11:12 pm, and you would probably arrive at your hotel 1 – 2 hours later.  That means you will be looking out over the dumpsters 17 miles from the lobby.  Blah.  I hate arriving late.

Final Tally

The bottom line is, it never really boils down to just cost.  Flight schedules play a huge part, too.  I thought I would be able to make the argument for non-stop flights in this post, and I really wanted to!  I’m sick of connecting flights, and would rather just hop on a plane and hop off at my destination.  It would be less tiring and more convenient.  But in these three examples, only one was a slam dunk for the nonstop flight.

Dang.

What would you do?  Would it be worth the extra money  to fly nonstop?  Or would you suck it up and take the connecting flight putting in the extra time and added risk of delays, etc?

Share in the comments!

About the author: Debbie Ferm is the founder of Travel Dither.  Get more family travel news in the Travel Dither Newsletter.  Sign up now.

Image courtesy of Swami Stream on Flickr

{ 6 comments }

When you fly with your family, the cost can get ugly pretty quickly.  We have five people in our family and if each ticket costs just $300 with taxes and fees, that’s $1500.  In my single days, I could have lived on that for a month,  maybe two!  So I’ve always searched carefully to get the most bang for the buck on our ticket prices, thinking we would have more money for fun when we got there.  Sometimes that decision put us on connecting flights.  No big deal.

After a couple of recent experiences, I’m rethinking my position.

In the last few weeks, I flew from Minneapolis to both Orlando and Acapulco.  Both had connecting flights.  The trip to and from Orlando was uneventful, but both ways had these whacked out connections, one through Philadelphia and the other through Dallas.  Really?  I need to go to Dallas to get from Orlando to Minneapolis?  (Well, I did get it on Priceline the day before, but still!  Heh.)  I guess the point is that a bell went off in my puny little brain that maybe it wasn’t worth the $80 I saved to fly around the entire US for a flight from Minneapolis to Orlando and back.  But the following week, my trip home from Acapulco solidified that thought.

The Flight From Hell

When I arrived at the Acapulco airport with my three travel companions, it was all good.  Our flight was “on time”, and we were good to go.  Except for the rude TSA employee that threw my shampoo and lotion in the garbage,  I was  happy as a clam.  The trip had been spectacular, and I was excited to see my family. 

Then I heard, “This is your captain, blah blah blah, maintenance issue, blah, blah, about an hour”, and I knew, I just knew, that we were screwed.

The maintenance issue turned into a weather issue,  turned into a rerouting to New Orleans when we were supposed to be in Houston.  Two people on our flight had been connecting through Houston to get home to New Orleans, so yay for them, right?  Wrong.  Customs had left the building (not unlike Elvis), and apparently no one else in the entire New Orleans airport is qualified to process two people back into the country!  What in the hell?  So those passengers had to continue on to Houston, where they had to spend the night before returning to New Orleans.   

Also, everyone on the flight was starving.  They sent someone to McDonalds to get burgers for the flight attendants but nothing for anyone else.  So  I guess no food at the New Orleans airport either.

I understand that there are federal regulations , (And we’d better get used to them because the federal government has been taking everything else over lately, too), but when the same things keep happening over and over, when people contine to get stuck sitting on hot airplanes for hours, perhaps a contingency plan is in order.  How hard can it be to make a rule that if a flight is going to be sitting on the ramp, someone should throw some sandwiches together?

The flight to Houston in the middle of the night hit turbulence that, had I not been wearing a seat belt, would have sent me into the ceiling more than once,  and probably out of my row altogether.  I scrunched my eyes up, held on for dear life, and thought about my kids, praying that we weren’t going to be vaporized somewhere in Texas.  My husband hates Texas.

After finally making it back to Minneapolis the next day, I started thinking about the actual time and financial cost of taking connecting vs. non-stop flights.  When does it make sense?  I did a little analysis.

I’ll be posting it tomorrow, but in the meantime, tell me your thoughts.  What do you usually do and why?

About the author: Debbie Ferm is the founder of Travel Dither.  Connect with Debbie at the Travel Dither page on Facebook!

{ 12 comments }

Gratuitous Fancy Travel Photo

I love to travel.  It inspires me and feeds my soul like almost nothing else does, my family, friends, and pets being the only thing I can think of at the moment.

The word “travel” has a sort of glamour and mystique to it that is fun to indulge in,  and there will definitely be times that I will do that on this website.  After all, I certainly don’t have enough glamour in my life, and none of the moms I know do either.

But, mostly, what I want this to be is a place where real moms can hang out.  Moms who have bigger concerns than which baby wipe warmer keeps the baby wipes their very warmest.  We all know that most of us who travel and take family vacations make real sacrifices to do it.

We’ve chosen LIFE style over life STYLE.

So if you are a regular mom, with a regular family, feeling like you want to travel with your family, but you aren’t the same as those fancy internet people, keep reading.

In the spirit of after school specials throughout the ages, I bring you…

A Very Special Photo Friday (You Know the Voice)

My 1994 Ford Explore bought before my 14 year old daughter was born.  When people see me in their neighborhood, they think I’m there to case the place.

My bedroom in the morning.  Half the time this is where I work.

Our one dinner “out” on vacation in Wisconsin Dells.

So while I share these with you today, and this is what my very unglamorous life looks like,  I can’t help thinking that you don’t want to look at these everyday around here.  Hell, even I don’t want to look at these.

Hence, the palm trees photos,  Lyrical essays , and spa reviews find their way in.

We all need a little of both in our lives.

Thanks for hanging around and leaving your comments.  It makes my day.

About the author: Debbie Ferm is the founder of Travel Dither.  You should sign up for the Travel Dither newsletter, because she really is going to write one someday, and you’re not going to want to miss it.

{ 5 comments }

How To Get a Same Day Passport

May 19, 2010

My recent trip to Acapulco wasn’t planned until the last minute, and I thought I was going to have to pass up the opportunity because of my expired passport. But, lo and behold, I learned that it doesn’t always require a sacrificial lamb and a month of Sundays to get a passport.  If you live [...]

0 comments Read the full article →

Acapulco -Was it a Dream? Also, the Contest Winner.

May 17, 2010

Park Royal Acapulco Last week I was a guest of the Park Royal Acapulco as part of an initiative to increase awareness of Acapulco as a destination for families.  I had four days to do some recon for my readers, enjoy the Acapulco sun, and sample the resort activities. Without question, the number one thing [...]

2 comments Read the full article →

Love Boat Prize – The Update

May 14, 2010

The Contest If you were here yesterday, then you know that I am in Acapulco as a guest of Royal Holiday being treated like a queen, and the Catholic guilt is getting to me.  So, in an effort to repent for committing 4 of the 7 deadly sins this week (I’ll leave you to guess which ones), I’m going to [...]

0 comments Read the full article →

Choose Your Own Prize Contest – Love Boat Edition

May 13, 2010

Acapulco Remember the Love Boat? I used to lo-ove the love boat!  When I was a babysitter, I would watch it and it was so glamorous watching all the people cruising to Acapulco.  Even the word A-ca-pu-lco sounded glamorous to my rural Wisconsin 12 year old ears.  I decided that some day I would go [...]

19 comments Read the full article →