My last post about nonstop or connecting flights detailed the reason why I’m beginning to question my habit of always choosing the least expensive flight when traveling with my family. After screwing around with connections that took me halfway across the country the wrong way, and then a harrowing flight wherein my life flashed before my eyes, I decided to take a look at three flights that represented flights we may realistically take as a family.
The Results
I checked a few different online outlets and ended up using Travelocity for this post.
Test Flight Number 1
Minneapolis to New York City June 22-29
Nonstop
Depart 11:15 am Arrive 3:00 pm
Total Cost = $315 with taxes and fees $345 per person/$1725 for a family of five
Connecting
Depart 7:55 am Arrive Chicago O’Hare 8:50 am
Depart Chicago O’Hare 10:40 am Arrive New York City 1:55 pm
Total Cost = $208 with taxes and fees $250 per person/ $1250 for a family of five
Difference in Price = $475
The connecting flight would get us to NY over an hour earlier, and cost $475 less, so on this one, I still think I’d choose the connecting flight. We’d have to face the early morning flight, but the morning of travel is a lost cause anyway. I would try to pack a bunch of snacks to get everyone through until we arrived in NY, but even if I had to spend $100 on food, I think it would be worth it in this instance. Of course, there’s always the chance that something could go wrong at O’Hare, which has happened before resulting in a 27 hour “vacation” in Chicago for my daughter and me. But I’m sticking with the connecting flight on this one.
That nonstop flight is so perfect though. If the connecting flight arrived any later in the day, I would be very tempted by the direct flight. Still, that $400 difference is a big deal to our family. It would get us one night in a hotel in New York:)
Test Flight Number 2
Minneapolis to Denver December 23-26
Nonstop
Depart anytime beginning at 6:30 am. Other flights 10:00 am, 2:08 pm, 6:55 pm. 2 hour flight.
Total Cost = $208 with taxes and fees $229/$1145 for a family of five
Connecting
The best price on connecting flights was also $208/$229.
Difference in Price = $0.00
Obviously, no question here. The nonstop flight is the winner. I was surprised that it was not more expensive to fly over Christmas to a ski friendly state. Definitely something to consider, although Denver is very driveable from Minneapolis, and $1145 is a tidy sum to shell out for 3 or 4 days.
Test Flight Number 3
Minneapolis to Orlando March 26-April 2
Nonstop
Option 1: Depart 7:00 pm Arrive 11:12 pm
Total cost = $448 with taxes and fees $469/$2345 for a family of five
Option 2 Depart 6:00 am Arrive 10:16 am.
Total cost = $581 with taxes and fees $613 per person/$3065 for a family of five.
Connecting
Depart 2:08 pm Arrive Chicago O’Hare 3:09 pm
Depart Chicago O’Hare 5:15 pm Arrive Orlando 9:22 pm
Total cost = $249 with taxes and fees $291/$1455 for a family of five
Difference in Price = $1510 or $$890.
Ugh, none of these options are any good. I might pass this one up and just drive. The nonstop flight departing at 6:00 am offers the friendliest schedule. Though it’s early in the morning, you wouldn’t lose an entire day of a week’s vacation. On the other hand, $3065 seems like a reasonable amount to get to Singapore, but not Orlando.
The flight connecting through Chicago isn’t too bad, although you do lose that entire day. At $1455 for five people, it is $890 less than the next lowest flight. There would definitely be an expense for food and drink of about $100. The problem with the nonstop in this scenario is that it doesn’t arrive until 11:12 pm, and you would probably arrive at your hotel 1 – 2 hours later. That means you will be looking out over the dumpsters 17 miles from the lobby. Blah. I hate arriving late.
Final Tally
The bottom line is, it never really boils down to just cost. Flight schedules play a huge part, too. I thought I would be able to make the argument for non-stop flights in this post, and I really wanted to! I’m sick of connecting flights, and would rather just hop on a plane and hop off at my destination. It would be less tiring and more convenient. But in these three examples, only one was a slam dunk for the nonstop flight.
Dang.
What would you do? Would it be worth the extra money to fly nonstop? Or would you suck it up and take the connecting flight putting in the extra time and added risk of delays, etc?
Share in the comments!
About the author: Debbie Ferm is the founder of Travel Dither. Get more family travel news in the Travel Dither Newsletter. Sign up now.
Image courtesy of Swami Stream on Flickr
{ 6 comments }











